Bathroom Remodeling & Cabinet Restyling in Colorado | HomePride

Maybe Don’t Hire Us: How to Vet a Bathroom Remodeler

Written by Coley O'Brien McAvoy | Feb 25, 2026 5:55:23 PM

Remodeling a bathroom isn’t just another home project.
It’s one of the most expensive upgrades you’ll make—and one of the most essential rooms in your home.  When it’s done right, it supports your daily routine, your safety, and your home’s long-term value.  When it’s done wrong, it can disrupt your life for weeks, create hidden water damage, and cost thousands more to fix.

That’s why choosing the right bathroom contractor is critical.

At HomePride Bath, we’ve seen what happens when homeowners are pressured into signing too quickly, given vague contracts, quoted unusually low bids, or left without proper permits and warranties.  We’ve also helped families fix projects that started with the wrong contractor.  Over the years, we’ve learned that trustworthy remodelers have one thing in common: their licensing, insurance, certifications, pricing, scope of work, and warranties can all be independently verified—without hesitation.

This guide will show you exactly how to verify a bathroom remodeler, recognize red flags early, and confidently walk away before risking your money, your safety, or your home.

The Biggest Takeaways

  • A trustworthy bathroom remodeler is one whose credentials, pricing, scope, and warranties can be independently verified.
  • Not every remodeler is right for every project — and that includes us.  Knowing when to walk away protects both your investment and your peace of mind.
  • In today’s economy, every dollar matters.  Choosing the right contractor the first time is critical, especially since most homeowners remodel a bathroom only once.
  • HomePride Bath specializes in walk-in tubs, tub-to-shower conversions, and accessible bathroom solutions — not full gut renovations, custom tile artistry, or multi-room remodels.
  • Trust indicators matter more than price.  BBB ratings, manufacturer certifications, verified reviews, and a proven track record tell you far more than the lowest bid ever will.
  • You should always verify a contractor’s credibility independently — including ours.  We’ll show you exactly how.
  • The wrong contractor choice costs more than money.  It can cost time, peace of mind, and even safety when accessibility work isn’t done correctly.

 

Why Does Trust Matter When Choosing a Bathroom Remodeler in Colorado’s Economy?

Trust matters because most homeowners remodel their bathroom only once, and mistakes are expensive to fix.  With projects often costing between $14,000 and $40,000, choosing the wrong contractor can lead to financial loss, safety risks, and months of disruption.

In today’s economy, Colorado homeowners are weighing every major investment carefully.  A bathroom remodel isn’t just another upgrade — it’s a significant financial commitment that needs to be done right the first time.  When there’s rarely a second chance to “fix it later,” trust isn’t optional — it’s essential.

Home improvement and construction consistently rank among the most serious consumer complaints nationwide.  A Consumer Federation of America survey found that home improvement ranked second only to automotive in total complaints, and first for “worst complaints” due to financial losses, incomplete work, and homes being left unlivable.  The Better Business Bureau has likewise reported record-setting numbers of home improvement disputes in recent years, with some regional cases exceeding $100,000 in homeowner losses.  Common issues include contractors disappearing mid-project, poor workmanship requiring costly corrections, and major cost overruns.

In an economy where every dollar counts, you can’t afford to be part of that statistic.

And here’s what makes this decision harder: everyone claims to be trustworthy.  Every website looks polished.  Every contractor has a few good reviews.

So let me start this article differently than you might expect:

Maybe you shouldn’t hire HomePride Bath.

We mean that sincerely.

If we’re not the right fit for your project, hiring us would waste your money — and our time. Neither of us can afford that. And that’s why we’ve written this article.

This article will show you:

  • When and why you can trust HomePride with your bathroom remodel
  • When you shouldn’t hire us
  • How to independently verify whether any contractor you’re considering actually deserves your trust

What Are the Real Risks of Choosing the Wrong Bathroom Remodeler?

Choosing the wrong bathroom remodeler can put your safety, finances, and home value at risk. Poor workmanship, incomplete projects, and accessibility mistakes often require starting over, costing homeowners significantly more than doing it right the first time.

For many Colorado families, a bathroom remodel is tied to:

  • Safety and independence — especially for aging-in-place needs, balance concerns, or mobility challenges
  • Home value protection — bathrooms heavily influence resale value in Colorado’s competitive housing market
  • Daily quality of life — you use this space every single day
  • Financial security — a failed remodel can devastate a household budget

Industry professionals report that fixing a poorly executed bathroom remodel often requires starting over entirely.  Contractors who specialize in repair work frequently see homeowners pay for their project twice — first for the failed installation, and again to have it done correctly.

That’s why this article isn’t a sales pitch.   It’s a decision framework — to help you decide whether HomePride Bath is the right fit for your situation, or whether you should look elsewhere.

What Red Flags Should You Watch for When Hiring a Bathroom Remodeler in Colorado?

Most remodeling disasters don’t start with obvious warning signs.  They start when homeowners don’t know what red flags to look for before signing a contract.  And by the time problems appear, it’s often too late to walk away.

When homeowners end up paying twice, it’s rarely because they made a careless decision.  More often, it’s because the warning signs weren’t obvious at the time — or they didn’t know what to look for until it was too late.  Remodeling is unfamiliar territory for most people, and the wrong contractor can sound convincing, professional, and trustworthy right up until problems start appearing behind the walls.

That’s why knowing the red flags before you sign a contract matters so much.  Once demolition begins, your leverage drops fast.  Your bathroom is torn apart, timelines slip, change orders pile up, and suddenly walking away feels impossible — even when your gut tells you something isn’t right.  The goal of this section isn’t to make you suspicious of every contractor, but to help you spot patterns that consistently lead to cost overruns, unfinished work, and legal headaches.

According to Consumer Reports, the Better Business Bureau (BBB), This Old House, NARI, and Angi, the following warning signs should give you serious pause — no matter how polished the sales pitch sounds.

Warning Signs That Should Make You Walk Away

Pressure to sign immediately or “today-only” pricing

  Pressure to sign immediately or “today-only” pricing

❌  Large upfront payment demands (more than one-third)

❌  No physical business address

❌  Unlicensed, uninsured, or skipping permits

❌  No recent references

❌  Vague or verbal-only contracts

❌  Suspiciously low bids

❌  Pressure to sign immediately or “today-only” pricing

❌  Large upfront payment demands (more than one-third)

❌  No physical business address

❌  Unlicensed, uninsured, or skipping permits

❌  No recent references

❌  Vague or verbal-only contracts

❌  Suspiciously low bids


Green Flags to Look For Instead

✅  Detailed written estimates

✅  Verifiable licensing and insurance

✅  Manufacturer certifications

✅  Long-term online review history

✅  Clear communication without pressure

✅  Transparent warranties

✅  Willingness to say when they’re not the right fit


 

What Questions Should You Ask Before Hiring Any Bathroom Remodeler?

Asking the right questions before signing a contract can prevent costly misunderstandings and unfinished projects. A trustworthy remodeler should answer these questions clearly, in writing, and without pressure — including us.

The right questions can save you thousands of dollars — and months of frustration. Most remodeling problems don’t happen because homeowners made bad choices; they happen because no one slowed down long enough to clarify expectations before work began.

This section gives you a practical set of questions to ask any bathroom remodeler, including us. A reputable company should welcome these conversations and answer clearly, in writing, without defensiveness or pressure. If a contractor avoids these topics, rushes your decision, or gives vague answers, that hesitation is often more revealing than the answers themselves.

Credentials and Experience

  • How long have you been in business?
  • Are you licensed and insured?
  • Can you provide recent references?

Scope, Products, and Permits

  • What’s included — and what’s not?
  • What products and warranties are used?
  • Who pulls permits?

Problems, Payment, and Communication

  • How are surprises handled?
  • What’s the payment schedule?
  • Who is my main point of contact?


Why Do Homeowners Trust HomePride Bath in Colorado and Cheyenne?

Homeowners trust HomePride Bath because our credentials, experience, and warranties can be independently verified.  Rather than asking you to take our word for it, we encourage you to verify our track record through third-party sources such as the BBB, Google, and KOHLER.  What follows is information you can — and should — verify yourself.

What follows isn’t about telling you why you should believe us — it’s about showing you the objective signals that responsible homeowners use to verify any contractor, backed up by trusted consumer advocates, including the BBB.  These are facts you can independently confirm, across third-party platforms that don’t belong to us and can’t be edited by us.

What follows isn’t a brag.  It’s verifiable information you can — and should — check yourself.

Our Track Record (That You Can Independently Verify)

  • 7 years in business with 2,000+ installations — Since 2019, we’ve completed more than 2,000 bathroom installations across Colorado and into Cheyenne, Wyoming.
  • AAA rating with the Better Business Bureau — The BBB’s highest rating, earned through transparency and consistent issue resolution.
  • Colorado’s original certified KOHLER dealer — Certification requires strict training, installation standards, and ongoing accountability.
  • 4.8+ star Google rating — Hundreds of verified reviews from real homeowners, publicly available and unfiltered.
  • 30+ person professional team — Installers, project coordinators, customer service, and support staff — not a one-person operation.

What These Credentials Actually Mean for You

In practical terms, this means:

  • We’ll still be here to honor limited lifetime warranties
  • Problems are addressed, not avoided
  • Installations follow manufacturer standards
  • Quality is consistent, not dependent on one person’s good day
  • Experience is based on thousands of completed projects, not promises

Most importantly: you can verify all of this yourself — on BBB.org, Google, and Team Dave Logan.  Real trust is transparent and checkable.

 

When Is HomePride Bath the Right Choice for Your Bathroom Remodel?

HomePride Bath is the right choice when your project aligns with our core expertise: safety-focused, accessibility-forward bathroom remodels completed within an existing footprint using manufacturer-backed systems.

Trust alone isn’t enough.  Even a reputable, well-reviewed company can be the wrong choice if its strengths don’t match your project.  Bathroom remodeling isn’t one-size-fits-all, and the smartest decision you can make is aligning your needs with a contractor’s actual expertise — not what they’re willing to sell you.

This next section outlines when HomePride Bath is the right choice for your project. If your priorities line up with what follows, our systems, products, and experience are designed to serve you well. If they don’t, that clarity matters just as much — because the goal isn’t to win your project, it’s to help you make the right call for your home.

  • You need a walk-in tub for safety or aging in place
  • You want a tub-to-shower conversion within the existing footprint
  • Accessibility, low-threshold entry, and long-term usability matter
  • You value KOHLER products and manufacturer-backed warranties
  • You want a proven company with systems and accountability
  • You prefer a dedicated team over a solo contractor
  • You live anywhere in Colorado or Cheyenne

Bathrooms and kitchen cabinet restyling are our specialties — and where our experience matters most.

 

When Is HomePride Bath Not the Right Choice for Your Remodel?)

Even reputable remodelers aren’t the right fit for every project.  HomePride Bath may not be the best choice if your goals require extensive structural changes, custom tile artistry, or multi-room renovations outside our specialized systems.

Just as important as knowing when a company is the right fit is knowing when they’re not. The fastest way to end up frustrated — or paying twice — is hiring a contractor whose business model doesn’t align with your expectations, timeline, or priorities.

At HomePride Bath, we believe it’s more responsible to say no upfront than to force a project that doesn’t fit our expertise or systems. The situations below aren’t “bad projects”, they simply require a different type of remodeler with a different business model. If any of these describe your goals, we’ll tell you honestly and help point you in the right direction.

You should look elsewhere if:

  • You want a complete bathroom gut renovation
  • You want plumbing moved/layouts changed
  • You want intricate custom tile or mosaics
  • Your project spans multiple rooms
  • Your sole priority is the lowest possible price
  • You want to DIY or source materials yourself

Being honest about these limits has cost us projects — and earned long-term trust.

Should You Hire HomePride?   A Clear Comparison

Project Scope

  • Good fit: Walk-in tubs, tub-to-shower conversions
  • Not a fit: Full bathroom gut remodels or tile-heavy redesigns

Layout Expectations

  • Good fit: Staying within the existing footprint
  • Not a fit: Moving plumbing, walls, or expanding into other rooms

Primary Priorities

  • Good fit: Accessibility, safety, long-term usability
  • Not a fit: Lowest price or design-first experimentation

Experience You Want

  • Good fit: A proven team with systems and warranties
  • Not a fit: A solo contractor or boutique design-build firm

Why This Comparison Matters

Choosing the right remodeler isn’t about finding the “best” company.  It’s about finding the best fit for your goals.  When expectations and expertise align, projects run more smoothly, costs stay predictable, and trust stays intact.

Scenario 1: When HomePride Was the Right Fit

A Safety-First Remodel, Chosen by a Contractor Fraud Specialist

Carol Hee didn’t choose HomePride Bath casually — and she certainly didn’t choose us because of a sales pitch.

A Pueblo homeowner, caregiver, and contractor fraud specialist, Carol spends part of her professional life educating homeowners about how remodeling projects go wrong.  She’s seen the consequences of unlicensed contractors, rushed decisions, and poorly executed work.  So when she decided to remodel her own bathroom, she approached the process with more scrutiny than most.

Carol’s situation was clear and focused:

  • She wanted to replace a spa tub with a walk-in shower before retirement.
  • She needed the project to improve safety and long-term usability, not just aesthetics.
  • She wanted to stay within the existing bathroom footprint, avoiding a full gut remodel.
  • Most importantly, she wanted a company whose credentials could be independently verified.

She did what many homeowners don’t — she checked licenses, BBB ratings, online reviews, and reputation before calling anyone.  HomePride stood out not because we promised more, but because our information held up under scrutiny.

During the consultation, there was no pressure to expand the project, no upselling, and no attempt to steer her toward something she didn’t need.  Instead, the conversation stayed focused on accessibility, comfort, and making the bathroom safer without unnecessary disruption.

For Carol, HomePride was the right fit because:

  • The project aligned exactly with our specialty (tub-to-shower conversion).
  • She valued KOHLER systems and manufacturer-backed warranties.
  • She wanted a team with proven systems and accountability.
  • She trusted verifiable credentials more than promises.

The result wasn’t just a new shower — it was peace of mind. And coming from someone whose job is spotting contractor fraud, that trust carries real weight.  

🎬  View Carol's testimony by clicking this link

Scenario 2: When HomePride Wasn’t the Right Fit

A Design-Driven, Multi-Room Remodel with Different Priorities

Another homeowner reached out to us with a very different vision.

They wanted:

  • A full bathroom gut renovation with custom tile and mosaic details.
  • Significant layout changes, including moving plumbing.
  • A project that would eventually expand into multiple rooms.
  • The flexibility to source some materials themselves.
  • And above all, they were comparing bids with price as the primary driver.

There was nothing wrong with their goals — but there was a mismatch.

HomePride’s systems are designed for efficiency, consistency, and safety-focused remodels within an existing footprint.  Custom artistic tilework, open-ended design experimentation, and multi-room renovations are better handled by boutique design-build firms or tile artisans who specialize in this type of work.

Rather than trying to make the project fit our model, we told them honestly that we weren’t the right partner — and why.

That decision protected both sides:

  • The homeowner avoided hiring a company whose strengths didn’t match their expectations.
  • We avoided taking on a project that would likely lead to frustration, delays, or compromises.

Walking away wasn’t a loss.  It was the right outcome.

Why These Scenarios Matter

Most remodeling problems don’t start with bad intentions — they start with misalignmentWhen homeowners understand who a company is built to serve (and who they aren’t), trust becomes clearer, decisions become easier, and outcomes improve.

That’s the standard we try to hold ourselves to — even when it means saying no.

How Can You Verify That HomePride Bath Is Actually Trustworthy?

Trust shouldn’t be assumed.  It should be earned and verified.  Any contractor can claim experience, quality, or integrity.  What separates a trustworthy company from a risky one is how easy it is for you to independently confirm those claims using third-party sources that don’t benefit from saying nice things.

This section shows you exactly how to check our credentials the same way informed homeowners, consumer advocates, and even contractor fraud specialists do.  No special access.  No insider knowledge.  Just straightforward steps you can take to confirm whether HomePride Bath — or any remodeler — deserves your trust.

  1. Check BBB.org — Search HomePride Bath Colorado and review the rating and complaint handling
  2. Read Google Reviews — Especially 1–2 star reviews for patterns
  3. Verify KOHLER Certification — Via KOHLER’s dealer locator or by calling 1-800-456-4537
  4. Confirm Licensing — Through Colorado’s Department of Regulatory Agencies
  5. Request References — Call us at (303) 350-3777 for recent customers and call them
  6. Compare Estimates — Use NARI’s written estimate standards

 

What Questions Should You Ask Before Hiring Any Bathroom Remodeler?

Asking the right questions before signing a contract can prevent costly misunderstandings and unfinished projects.  A trustworthy remodeler should answer these questions clearly, in writing, and without pressure — including us.

The right questions can save you thousands of dollars — and months of frustration.  Most remodeling problems don’t happen because homeowners made bad choices; they happen because no one slowed down long enough to clarify expectations before work began.

This section gives you a practical set of questions to ask any bathroom remodeler, including us.  A reputable company should welcome these conversations and answer clearly, in writing, without defensiveness or pressure.  If a contractor avoids these topics, rushes your decision, or gives vague answers, that hesitation is often more revealing than the answers themselves.

Credentials and Experience

  • How long have you been in business?
  • Are you licensed and insured?
  • Can you provide recent references?

Scope, Products, and Permits

  • What’s included — and what’s not?
  • What products and warranties are used?
  • Who pulls permits?

Problems, Payment, and Communication

  • How are surprises handled?
  • What’s the payment schedule?
  • Who is my main point of contact?

 

What Do HomePride Bath’s Warranties and Guarantees Actually Cover?

Remodeling warranties only protect you when you understand what’s covered and what isn’t.  This section explains how HomePride Bath’s labor guarantee and KOHLER product warranties work together to protect your investment.

Guarantees only matter when you understand what they actually protect — and what they don’t.  In remodeling, vague warranty language is often where confusion, disappointment, and disputes begin.  That’s why clarity here is just as important as craftsmanship.

This section explains, in plain terms, how our guarantees work, how manufacturer warranties and our labor coverage fit together, and where responsibility reasonably ends.  The goal isn’t to promise perfection forever — it’s to give you a clear understanding of how your investment is protected after the installation is complete.

KOHLER Limited Lifetime Warranties

KOHLER backs many products with limited lifetime warranties — supported by our certified installation.

Our Labor Guarantee

If an installation issue results from our workmanship, we make it right.

What’s Not Covered

  • Normal wear and tear
  • Improper use or maintenance
  • Modifications by other contractors
  • Pre-existing issues disclosed prior to install

What Happens Next If You Decide to Explore HomePride Bath?

Exploring your options shouldn’t feel like a commitment.   Our process is designed to give you clarity first — so you can decide when, how, and if you want to move forward.

Here’s exactly what happens if you choose to explore HomePride Bath as an option.  No obligation.  No surprise pressure.  Just a straightforward process designed to help you decide — on your timeline — whether we’re the right fit for your home and your goals.

Step 1: Schedule a Free In-Home Consultation

We listen, assess, and tell you honestly whether we’re a fit.

Step 2: Receive a Detailed Written Estimate

Clear scope, products, timeline, and warranties — no pressure.

Step 3: Decide on Your Timeline

Compare options, ask questions, and decide when you’re ready.

 

Final Thoughts: Trust Is Earned, Not Claimed

Trust isn’t built by saying the right things.  It’s built by transparency, limitations, verification, and accountability.

In 7 years and 2,000+ installations, we’ve learned that the best-fit customers are informed, thoughtful, and careful with their investment.  Those homeowners value experience, systems, warranties, and honesty.

Whether you hire HomePride Bath or another contractor, use this framework to make an informed decision.  You’re only going to remodel your bathroom once — it needs to be done right.

If you think HomePride might be a good fit, start with a no-pressure conversation:

👉 https://www.homepridebath.com/start-your-remodel

We’ll tell you the truth — even if that truth is that we’re not the right choice.

 

 

Frequently Asked Questions

1.  How do I verify a bathroom remodeler in Colorado before hiring them?

To verify a bathroom remodeler in Colorado, check their licensing and insurance, confirm their business address, review their BBB rating, read Google reviews (including low-star reviews for patterns), verify manufacturer certifications like KOHLER, and request recent references.  A trustworthy contractor will provide written estimates, pull the necessary permits, and encourage you to independently verify their credentials.

2.  What are the biggest red flags when hiring a bathroom contractor?

The biggest red flags include pressure to sign immediately, “today-only” pricing, large upfront payment demands (more than one-third), vague or verbal-only contracts, lack of licensing or insurance, skipping permits, no recent references, and bids that are significantly lower than competitors.  These warning signs often lead to cost overruns, unfinished work, or safety issues.

3.  Why is choosing the right bathroom remodeler so important?

Bathroom remodels are expensive—often ranging from $14,000 to $40,000—and most homeowners only remodel once.  Choosing the wrong contractor can result in hidden water damage, failed inspections, accessibility hazards, project delays, and paying twice to fix mistakes. The right contractor protects your investment, your safety, and your home's long-term value.

4.  When is HomePride Bath the right fit for a bathroom remodel?

HomePride Bath is a strong fit for walk-in tubs, tub-to-shower conversions, and accessibility-focused remodels completed within the existing bathroom footprint.  Homeowners who value manufacturer-backed systems, KOHLER-certified installation, structured processes, and long-term warranties are typically the best match.

5.  When should I look for a different bathroom remodeling company?

You should consider another contractor if your project requires moving plumbing, expanding into multiple rooms, full gut renovations, intricate custom tile work, or if your only priority is the lowest possible price.  Hiring a company whose expertise aligns with your goals prevents misalignment, delays, and costly revisions.

 

Related Articles

Better Business Bureau (BBB). How to Choose a Home Improvement Contractor. https://www.bbb.org/article/news-releases/27396-bbb-tip-how-to-choose-a-home-improvement-contractor

National Association of the Remodeling Industry (NARI). 20 Questions to Ask When Hiring a Remodeler. https://www.nari.org/homeowners

Consumer Reports. How to Hire a Contractor and Avoid Scams. https://www.consumerreports.org/home-garden/home-improvement/how-to-hire-a-contractor/

This Old House. How to Hire a Contractor You Can Trust. https://www.thisoldhouse.com/home-finances/21015295/how-to-hire-a-contractor

Angi. Red Flags When Hiring a Contractor. https://www.angi.com/articles/red-flags-hiring-contractor.htm